ChapterHouse Declares Victory in Court Case

By Rob Baer | June 18th, 2013 | Categories: Chapterhouse, Legal, News / Rumors

Well Chapterhouse’s legal councel released a pres release basically touting vicotry in a “David and Goliath” manner over Games Workshop Monday.

This ruling seems to not only clear the way for more bits products to come to market, but also positions Winston & Stawn as defenders of trademark policy when applied to add on products.  That’s pretty much a decision that can have far reaching effect as it can apply to any assembled product made, that could be customized aftermarket (from model kits to automobiles).

Sure Chapterhouse has to pay some money and some of their items can no longer be sold, but it seems like it was a small price to pay to slap GW’s hand.

So what does it all mean? Well I guess it’s too soon to tell 100%, but I would imagine that a certain company in Nottingham isn’t too happy with the events of last week (or the expenses incurred therein).

Full story below- MBG

Courtsey of Apocalypse 40k

Posted by Loken at 6/18/2013 03:44:00 AM

A press release from Chapterhouse Studios’ Law Firm tells the tale pretty well.   Games Workshop got spanked for its overreach.  Chapterhouse has done the after market parts business a huge favor.

Winston & Strawn Defeats Hundreds of Trademark and Copyright Infringement Claims on Behalf of Pro Bono Client

Cutting-Edge Decision Protects Industries from Litigation Blocking Add-On Products

CHICAGO, IL – In a classic David-versus-Goliath battle, Winston & Strawn LLP represented Chapterhouse Studios LLC on a pro bono basis in a cutting-edge federal trademark and copyright dispute in the Northern District of Illinois (Games Workshop Limited v. Chapterhouse Studios LLC 1:10-cv-8103). The verdict of this jury trial, held in June 2013 before Judge Matthew Kennelly, confirms that copyright and trademark law should not be used to block add-on products. Winston & Strawn has litigated the case since 2010, and co-counsel law firm Marshall Gerstein joined the matter in 2012.

“This was a classic case of trademark and copyright bullying by a much bigger Plaintiff,” said Jennifer Golinveaux, partner in Winston & Strawn’s San Francisco office. “I am proud of the investment made by the firm, and the many attorneys who devoted themselves to making sure the intellectual property laws were not misused to squash a much smaller player.”

Games Workshop manufactures Warhammer 40,000, a tabletop battle game that works with armies of miniature figures and vehicles, while Chapterhouse sells customized add-on parts for the figures and vehicles used in the game. The United Kingdom-based Games Workshop, a company with $200 million per year in revenues, alleged more than 200 claims of copyright and trademark infringement against Chapterhouse, a small business run out of an individual’s garage in Texas. Games Workshop argued that it was seeking a complete shutdown of Chapterhouse’s entire business and although Games Workshop initially sought over $400,000 in damages, by the end of the two-week jury trial, the plaintiff dropped its damages demand to only $25,000.

The jury deliberated for more than two days and found that Chapterhouse could continue to make and sell over a hundred products without fear of copyright infringement. The jury also confirmed that Chapterhouse could continue to use most of Games Workshop’s asserted trademarks when selling compatible parts, including all nine of Games Workshop’s registered trademarks. Together with the summary judgment wins, the jury’s verdict confirmed Chapterhouse can continue to make and sell 111 products that Games Workshop hoped to block using copyright laws, and can continue to use 104 words and phrases that Games Workshop said were trademarked.

Imron Aly, lead trial attorney and partner in Winston & Strawn’s Chicago office added, “It was a pleasure to represent a small entrepreneur like Nicholas Villacci of Chapterhouse, who has a passion for his work and wanted to see his business survive.”

I for one am so happy that Chapterhouse did well in this case.  Games Workshop is a bully and deserved to get slapped.  

Not that I expect them to change their behavior.  At least now it is pretty clear that the bitz business is legal and some guidelines are there to help.


About the Author: Rob Baer

Virginia Restless, Miniature Painter & Cat Dad. I blame LEGOs. There was something about those little-colored blocks that started it all... Twitter @catdaddymbg
Go to Top